Related Articles
In a time where everything seems to be focused on efficiency and immediate results, it is easy to fall into the temptation of seeing prayer as merely a means to get what we want. Many Christians, often unconsciously, adopt an instrumentalist view of prayer: “If I pray, God will give me what I ask for.” But this is not the true essence of Christian prayer.
Prayer is not a trick to make God fulfill our wishes, nor is it a transaction where we give something to receive something in return. Prayer is much deeper: it is an encounter with God, a dialogue of love in which the soul surrenders to His will and opens itself to His grace.
Throughout the history of the Church, saints and great spiritual teachers have repeatedly emphasized that prayer is not a means to obtain what we want, but the space where God transforms us to want what He wants.
In this article, we will explore the true meaning of Christian prayer, its history, its theological foundation, and its relevance for our time. We will also refute the Protestant perspective that rejects certain forms of prayer as “mechanical” or “incorrect.”
1. What Is Christian Prayer?
Prayer is the act by which human beings enter into communion with God. The Catechism of the Catholic Church states:
“Prayer is the raising of one’s mind and heart to God or the requesting of good things from God” (CCC 2559).
This means that prayer is not only about asking for things but is, above all, a relationship with God. Like any relationship, it involves speaking and listening, expressing oneself, and allowing oneself to be transformed by the other.
In Christian tradition, prayer takes various forms: adoration, praise, thanksgiving, intercession, and supplication. But in all of them, the focus is on God. It is not about using prayer as a “tool” to achieve a goal, but about making prayer a way of life—a state of the soul that seeks God for who He is, not just for what He can give.
2. The History and Origin of Christian Prayer
Prayer is not an invention of Christianity. From the very beginning of human history, people have felt the need to turn to God. In the Old Testament, we find numerous examples of prayer, from the Psalms of David to the supplications of the prophets. However, it is with Jesus Christ that prayer reaches its fullness.
Jesus and Prayer
Jesus taught us to pray not only with words but with His own life. He withdrew to the desert to pray (Lk 5:16), spent entire nights in prayer (Lk 6:12), and taught His disciples to address God as “Father” with the Lord’s Prayer (Mt 6:9-13).
But most importantly, Jesus showed us that prayer is not a means to obtain things, but a trusting surrender to the Father’s will. In Gethsemane, in His most difficult hour, He did not say, “Lord, give me what I want,” but rather:
“Father, if you are willing, remove this cup from me; nevertheless, not my will, but yours, be done” (Lk 22:42).
Here lies the heart of true prayer: not trying to bend God to our desires but surrendering ourselves to His.
Prayer in the Tradition of the Church
From the earliest centuries, Christians understood prayer as a relationship with God, not just as a mechanism for obtaining favors. The Church Fathers, such as St. Augustine and St. John Chrysostom, emphasized that prayer does not change God but changes us.
St. Augustine wrote:
“The purpose of prayer is not to inform God, but to form the one who prays.”
This means that, although we may ask God for things, the essence of prayer is growth in faith and trust in Him.
The Desert Fathers, great mystics like St. Teresa of Avila and St. John of the Cross, and saints like St. Francis of Assisi lived this truth: prayer is not about asking, but about loving.
3. The Error of Instrumental Prayer
Today, many people fall into a distorted view of prayer. Sometimes it is reduced to a simple “Do this for me” or to a series of formulas repeated only to obtain benefits. Even some Christian movements, influenced by modern thinking, preach a “prosperity gospel” where prayer becomes a technique for achieving material success.
However, this view is wrong because:
- It distorts the relationship with God, reducing Him to a “genie in a bottle” who exists to grant wishes.
- It leads to spiritual frustration, because if God does not grant what is asked for, one’s faith may weaken.
- It forgets the Cross, since Christianity does not promise a life without difficulties, but rather the grace to face them with hope.
Jesus did not teach us to demand things from God but to trust in His providence. As St. Paul says:
“We know that all things work together for good for those who love God” (Rom 8:28).
This means that even if our requests are not granted as we expect, God is always working for our good.
4. What Do Protestants Say, and How Do We Respond?
Some Protestant groups reject certain forms of prayer, particularly repetitive prayer like the Rosary, arguing that it consists of “vain repetitions” (Mt 6:7). They also distrust the intercession of the saints, claiming that one should pray only directly to God.
However, these objections are unfounded:
- Jesus Himself repeated prayers, as in Gethsemane, where He said the same thing three times (Mt 26:44). Repetitive prayer is not bad if it is done with faith and love.
- The Lord’s Prayer is a fixed prayer that Jesus Himself taught, proving that God does not reject formulaic prayers.
- The intercession of the saints is biblical, as in Revelation, where the saints present the prayers of the faithful to God (Rev 5:8).
Therefore, the Protestant rejection of these forms of prayer is unfounded and contradicts Christian practice from the earliest centuries.
5. Conclusion: Prayer Is Communion, Not Manipulation
True Christian prayer is not an attempt to “use” God but to love Him and trust in Him.
St. Teresa of Avila said:
“Prayer is nothing else than being on terms of friendship with God, who we know loves us.”
This is the essence of Christian prayer: an encounter with the living God, who hears us, loves us, and leads us to true joy.
So, the next time you pray, don’t think only about what you can receive. Think about who is on the other end: a loving Father who wants the best for you.
Trust in Him—and let prayer transform your life.
