Related Articles
We live in an age fascinated by motivation.
Inspirational phrases, self-improvement videos, personal-growth books, speeches about success, applications that remind us of our goals, habit trackers, thirty-day challenges, images with messages such as “you can do it,” “never give up,” or “pursue your dreams.”
Everything seems designed to make us feel sufficiently motivated to begin.
And certainly, motivation can be something good. It can awaken a decision, bring about a change, pull us out of apathy, or help us begin a journey.
But there is a problem when we make it the foundation of our lives:
motivation is a feeling, and feelings are variable.
Today we may feel full of enthusiasm and tomorrow completely empty. Today we may get up with a desire to pray, study, exercise, put our lives in order, or fulfill our duties; tomorrow perhaps we will have no desire whatsoever.
If our life depends on how we feel, our life will necessarily be unstable.
And here we encounter a distinction of enormous importance for Christian life:
We do not need to be motivated to do good. We need to be formed to do it.
The difference may seem small, but in reality it profoundly affects our understanding of the human person.
Motivation asks:
“Do I feel like doing it?”
Virtue asks:
“Is it good to do it?”
Motivation says:
“I will do it as long as it inspires me.”
Virtue responds:
“I will do it because it is my duty and because I love the good.”
Motivation depends greatly on our state of mind.
Virtue progressively transforms our character.
Therefore, from a Christian perspective, we should not build our existence upon motivation, but upon truth, the will, good habits, and virtues, sustained by the grace of God.
1. The Problem of a Society Obsessed with Feeling Good
One of the most characteristic features of our age is that we have turned our emotional state into a kind of moral criterion.
“If it makes me feel good, it must be good.”
“If it no longer makes me happy, I must abandon it.”
“If I do not feel anything when I pray, perhaps prayer is not for me.”
“If I am not motivated to go to Mass, why should I go?”
“If I do not feel like forgiving, I cannot do it.”
“If I no longer feel the same way about my marriage, perhaps love has ended.”
But Christian tradition has never identified the good with pleasant feelings.
Christianity knows something fundamental about human nature: our emotions are real, but they are not our master.
We possess intelligence and will. We have affections, passions, and feelings, but we must not make them the supreme criterion of our conduct.
A mature person is not someone who always feels like doing good.
It is someone who has learned to do good even when he does not feel like doing it.
And this is particularly important in the spiritual life.
Because there will come a time when praying will be difficult.
There will be days when attending Mass will require an effort.
There will be moments when forgiveness seems impossible.
There will be seasons when reading the Gospel produces no particular emotion.
There will be occasions when Christian life seems dry, demanding, or even burdensome.
What do we do then?
If we have built our faith upon motivation, we will probably abandon it.
If we have built our faith upon virtue, we will persevere.
2. Our Lord Does Not Ask Only for Enthusiasm: He Asks for Obedience
There is a teaching of Our Lord Jesus Christ that is extraordinarily relevant today.
At the end of the Sermon on the Mount, Christ speaks of two men who build a house.
One builds upon rock.
The other upon sand.
The difference is not simply that one heard Christ and the other did not.
The difference is in doing.
Our Lord says:
“Everyone who hears these words of mine and puts them into practice will be like a wise man who built his house on rock.”
And then He warns about the one who hears but does not put His words into practice: his house is built on sand. When the rain, rivers, and winds come, the house falls. (biblegateway.com)
This parable contains an authentic spiritual anthropology.
Christ does not say:
“Blessed is the one who feels inspired by my words.”
He says, in essence:
“Blessed is the one who hears them and puts them into practice.”
Here we find the difference between a spirituality based on emotion and a spirituality based on virtue.
Emotion can begin a construction.
But only the strength of the foundations allows it to withstand the storm.
3. Motivation Can Begin the Journey, but It Cannot Sustain It
It would be unfair to say that motivation is useless.
It is useful.
A person may experience a powerful inspiration after a spiritual retreat, a sermon, a pilgrimage, confession, a conversation with a priest, or even after reading a good book.
That enthusiasm can be a providential grace.
It can lead the person to say:
“I have to change.”
And that decision can be very important.
The problem arises when we confuse the beginning of the journey with perseverance along the journey.
Motivation can say:
“Starting tomorrow I am going to pray the Rosary every day.”
Virtue responds:
“Today I am tired, but I am going to pray it anyway.”
Motivation says:
“I am going to study theology.”
Virtue responds:
“Today I do not feel like it, but I will study these pages because I want to form my intellect in the truth.”
Motivation says:
“I want to become more patient.”
Virtue responds:
“This person is irritating me, but I am going to control my reaction and treat him with charity.”
Motivation says:
“I want to be a good Christian.”
Virtue responds:
“Today I am going to behave as a Christian.”
And that difference is enormous.
4. You Do Not Need to Feel Like It in Order to Do Good
This statement can be revolutionary for the contemporary mentality:
you do not need to feel like doing something in order for it to be good.
This does not mean that feelings are bad.
On the contrary.
Human affections have an important function and can cooperate with reason and the will.
The problem arises when we give them control over our lives.
Imagine a person who wants to pray every evening.
At first he is enthusiastic.
He buys a Rosary.
He looks for prayers.
He organizes a schedule.
For two weeks he is delighted.
Then tiredness arrives.
One day he goes to bed late.
Another day he has problems.
Another day he simply does not feel like praying.
If his spiritual system depended upon motivation, he would give up.
But if he has begun developing a virtuous habit of prayer, something different will happen.
He may say:
“Today I do not feel anything special. But I am going to pray.”
That is maturity.
Not because he is acting mechanically, but because his will is learning to love the good beyond his emotional states.
5. Christian Life Cannot Depend on Our State of Mind
This has enormous importance for Catholic spirituality.
Let us imagine several situations.
“Today I do not feel like praying.”
Pray.
Perhaps you cannot spend an hour in prayer. Spend fifteen minutes.
But do not confuse the absence of consolation with the absence of God.
“Today I do not feel like going to Mass.”
The Sunday obligation does not depend upon our emotional state.
Holy Mass does not acquire its value because we are having a good day.
“Today I do not feel like forgiving.”
Precisely there begins the exercise of virtue.
“Today I am too tired to help.”
Perhaps you genuinely need to rest. Prudence is also a virtue.
But if it is simply a matter of comfort, we must learn to overcome it.
“I do not feel like studying the Faith.”
Precisely for that reason we need intellectual discipline.
Saint Peter exhorts Christians to be prepared to give an account of their hope:
“Always be ready to give an answer to everyone who asks you to give the reason for the hope that you have.”
Faith should not be reduced to religious feelings.
It also needs formation, intelligence, and knowledge of the truth.
6. Saint Thomas Aquinas: Virtue as a Stable Habit of the Good
Here we enter the heart of Catholic tradition.
The Christian understanding of virtue has deep roots in classical philosophy, especially Aristotle, but it reaches an extraordinary development in Saint Thomas Aquinas.
For Saint Thomas, virtue is not simply a pleasant emotion or an occasional good intention.
It is a habitus, a stable disposition that perfects our faculties and disposes us to act well.
The Summa Theologiae devotes an extensive section to the study of virtues, precisely because for Saint Thomas moral life does not consist merely in performing isolated actions, but in forming the person who performs those actions. (newadvent.org)
This distinction is fundamental.
A person can accidentally perform a good act without yet possessing the corresponding virtue.
For example:
A man can tell the truth once.
But that does not necessarily mean that he is a truthful person.
He can be generous one afternoon.
But that does not necessarily mean that he has acquired the virtue of generosity.
He can pray fervently for a week.
But that does not necessarily mean that he has developed a stable prayer life.
Virtue appears when the good begins to become a firm disposition of the person.
That is why Saint Thomas defines human virtue as a good operative habit. (newadvent.org)
In simple terms:
Virtue turns the good we want to do into a stable way of living.
And here we find an extraordinarily powerful answer to the culture of motivation.
7. You Do Not Need to Feel Like It in Order to Do Good
There is a temptation to think that if something is truly important, we should always feel enthusiastic about it.
But this is not how human life works.
A mother does not need to feel motivated every time she cares for her child.
A father does not need to feel inspired every time he fulfills his responsibilities.
A worker does not need to be enthusiastic every morning in order to work honestly.
And a Christian does not need to experience spiritual enthusiasm every time he prays.
Faithfulness is greater than temporary enthusiasm.
This is why Christian maturity requires us to move from:
“I do it because I feel like it”
to:
“I do it because it is good.”
Eventually, something beautiful can happen.
Through repeated acts, the good becomes easier.
What was initially difficult can become natural.
What once required a great struggle can eventually become almost spontaneous.
That is one of the fruits of virtue.
8. Holiness Is Not Built in Great Moments, but in Small Acts of Fidelity
There is a very modern temptation to imagine holiness as something spectacular.
We think of great conversions, extraordinary spiritual experiences, pilgrimages, apparitions, great penances, or moments of intense religious emotion.
But ordinary Christian life is often built in a much more humble way.
Getting up when it is time.
Fulfilling one’s duty.
Working honestly.
Not responding with anger.
Guarding one’s eyes.
Controlling one’s tongue.
Not gossiping.
Forgiving.
Keeping a promise.
Praying even when tired.
Going to confession.
Attending Mass.
Studying Catholic doctrine.
Helping at home.
Being faithful to one’s state in life.
Accepting a setback without immediately turning it into a tragedy.
These things may seem small.
But repeated over years they form character.
And character determines to a great extent how we will act when the great trials arrive.
9. Virtues Prepare Us for the Day Motivation Disappears
The true test of moral formation is not what we do when everything is easy.
It is what we do when things become difficult.
A disciplined person does not need to negotiate with himself every morning.
He does not have to ask:
“Do I feel like getting up?”
He gets up.
He does not have to ask:
“Do I feel like fulfilling my obligation?”
He fulfills it.
He does not have to wait until he feels charitable in order to avoid a hurtful word.
He avoids it.
This does not mean that the virtuous person is a machine.
It means that he has acquired greater freedom.
Because there is an extraordinary paradox:
Virtue does not limit our freedom; it frees us from slavery to our impulses.
A person who cannot govern himself is not truly free.
He is a slave to his appetites.
If he eats whenever he feels like it, sleeps whenever he feels like it, speaks whenever he feels like it, responds whenever he feels like it, works whenever he feels like it, and prays whenever he feels like it, his life is governed by impulses.
Virtue introduces order.
Reason illuminates.
The will chooses.
And the person progressively learns to live according to the good.
10. The Four Cardinal Virtues: An Architecture for Life
Catholic tradition speaks of four cardinal virtues:
prudence, justice, fortitude, and temperance.
They are not merely abstract concepts.
They are true pillars of moral life.
Prudence
It teaches us to discern correctly what we ought to do.
Prudence does not mean cowardice or excessive caution.
It means rightly applying reason to action.
We ask ourselves:
What is good here? What should I do? What is the right way to act?
Justice
It inclines us to give each person what is due to him.
It reminds us of our duties toward God and toward our neighbor.
Justice even begins with recognizing that God is God and we are creatures.
From this arises the virtue of religion, which is closely connected with justice.
Fortitude
It enables us to persevere in the good despite difficulties.
Here we find precisely one of the great antidotes to dependence upon motivation.
The strong person does not say:
“I will do it if I feel like it.”
He says:
“It is difficult, but I must do it.”
Temperance
It orders our desires and pleasures according to reason.
In a society dominated by consumption, immediate gratification, screens, and constant entertainment, this virtue is particularly necessary.
11. And Then There Are the Theological Virtues
But Christianity is not merely a kind of self-discipline program.
Here we encounter a fundamental difference.
The Christian does not simply seek to become an efficient person.
He wants to live in God and for God.
That is why there are the three theological virtues:
faith, hope, and charity.
Faith unites us to God as Truth.
Hope directs us toward God as our future and definitive Good.
Charity unites us to God through love and orders our love for our neighbor.
Here Christian life reaches a depth that no modern motivation system can provide.
It is not simply a matter of saying:
“I am going to become a better person.”
It is a matter of saying:
“I want to belong to Christ.”
And that completely changes the meaning of discipline.
We do not pray simply to feel better.
We pray because God deserves our worship.
We do not avoid sin simply to feel proud of ourselves.
We avoid it because sin offends God and harms our soul.
We do not practice charity simply to improve our self-esteem.
We love because Christ has commanded us to love.
12. Charity Is Greater Than Any Motivation Program
Here we arrive at the heart of Christian morality.
Saint Paul writes:
“Though I have faith that can move mountains, if I do not have charity, I am nothing.”
Charity is not simply “being nice.”
It is supernatural love for God above all things and for our neighbor for the love of God.
Therefore, a virtuous life must not become pure perfectionism.
There is a danger even within discipline:
turning virtue into pride.
“Look how much I can do.”
“Look how disciplined I am.”
“Look at how early I get up.”
“Look at how many Rosaries I pray.”
“Look at how much I know.”
That can become a spiritual form of vanity.
Christian virtue does not end in ourselves.
It orders us toward God.
And without grace, supernatural life cannot be reduced to a simple technique of self-control.
13. Grace Does Not Replace Our Efforts: It Transforms Them
Catholic doctrine maintains an extraordinary balance.
On the one hand:
we cannot save ourselves by our own strength.
On the other:
grace does not eliminate our cooperation.
God gives us His grace, but we must respond.
God calls us, but we must follow Him.
God offers us His mercy, but we must convert.
God grants us help, but we must cooperate with it.
Therefore Christian life requires prayer, the sacraments, formation, the struggle against sin, works of mercy, and the exercise of virtue.
Not in order to “earn” God’s love as though we were accumulating points.
But because the grace we receive must truly transform our lives.
14. Virtue Is Built Through Repetition
Here we encounter a very important idea.
We do not normally acquire a virtue by performing a single good action.
Virtue is strengthened through the repetition of good acts.
This means that our small daily actions have far greater importance than we often imagine.
Every time we control an angry response, we are exercising meekness.
Every time we fulfill a difficult duty, we strengthen fortitude.
Every time we reject an excess, we exercise temperance.
Every time we give someone what is due to him, we exercise justice.
Every time we deliberately seek the truth, we strengthen our intellectual life.
Every time we pray even though we do not feel like it, we are forming a stable disposition toward God.
We should not despise small acts.
They are bricks.
And a house is built with bricks.
15. The Parable of the House on the Rock Is Also a Pedagogy of Habits
Let us return to Christ’s image.
The house is not built at the moment of the storm.
The house is built beforehand.
When the storm arrives, it is too late to begin laying the foundations.
This has an enormous spiritual application.
We cannot wait until we are in a crisis to begin forming our character.
We cannot wait for illness to learn to trust God.
We cannot wait for a great temptation to learn to control our desires.
We cannot wait for a marital conflict to learn to forgive.
We cannot wait for persecution to learn to stand firm.
We cannot wait until old age to begin seeking God.
Virtue is acquired before the storm.
And when the storm comes, we discover whether we have truly built upon rock.
16. Motivation Is Especially Dangerous When Applied to Faith
There is a phrase that is often heard:
“I do not feel God.”
But Christian life does not consist in constantly feeling God.
The saints also knew spiritual dryness.
Prayer can be consoling.
But it can also be dry.
There can be moments when prayer is a profoundly joyful experience.
And others when it is simply an act of fidelity.
And perhaps those latter moments have extraordinary spiritual value.
Because when we pray only because we experience consolation, there is a danger that, in reality, we are seeking consolation more than God.
When we continue praying even without feeling anything, we are learning to say:
“Lord, I do not seek You only for what You make me feel. I seek You because You are God.”
That is a much deeper spiritual maturity.
17. Habits Can Be Holy When They Are Ordered Toward the Good
The word “habit” can sound modern, as though we were simply talking about productivity.
But the classical concept of habitus is much deeper.
It is not simply about automating behaviors.
It is about forming our faculties so that they are disposed toward the good.
Therefore, we can establish concrete habits:
- getting up at a set time;
- reserving a daily moment for prayer;
- making an examination of conscience;
- reading something from Catholic doctrine every day;
- going to confession regularly;
- attending Mass;
- praying the Rosary;
- observing certain moments of silence;
- controlling the use of social media;
- avoiding conversations that lead us into sin;
- practicing works of mercy;
- cultivating spiritual reading;
- working diligently;
- fulfilling our family obligations.
But all these habits must have a direction.
We do not want to become perfectly organized people.
We want to become people ordered toward the good and toward God.
18. Do Not Confuse Christian Discipline with Perfectionism
This point is pastorally essential.
There are people who, after discovering the importance of virtue, fall into the opposite extreme.
They impose twenty obligations upon themselves.
Three Rosaries.
An hour of meditation.
Spiritual reading.
Fasting.
Exercise.
Study.
Penance.
Numerous devotions.
And then they cannot maintain everything.
They feel guilty.
They give up.
And they start again.
That is not a good strategy either.
Virtue requires prudence.
It is better to establish a few practices and fulfill them faithfully than to build a gigantic program that lasts ten days.
It is not about doing a lot.
It is about doing things well and persevering.
A small rule of life faithfully followed for years can profoundly transform a person.
19. How Do We Move from Motivation to Virtue?
We can turn this entire reflection into a very simple method.
First: Define the Good
Do not first ask:
“What do I feel like doing?”
Ask:
“What is good?”
Christian morality begins with truth.
Second: Identify the Virtue You Need
Are you lacking patience?
Work on meekness.
Do you struggle to control your desires?
Work on temperance.
Do you give up easily?
Work on fortitude.
Do you struggle to fulfill your obligations?
Work on diligence and justice.
Do you lack consistency in prayer?
Work on fidelity and perseverance.
Third: Establish a Concrete Practice
Do not say:
“I am going to become holier.”
That is too abstract.
Say:
“Every night, before going to sleep, I will devote ten minutes to prayer and an examination of conscience.”
Virtue requires concrete acts.
Fourth: Eliminate Emotional Negotiation
Do not ask yourself every day:
“Do I feel like it?”
Ask:
“Is it time?”
If it is time to pray, pray.
If it is time to work, work.
If it is time to fulfill an obligation, fulfill it.
Discipline reduces the constant negotiation with our moods.
Fifth: Persevere After Failing
This point is decisive.
You will fail.
We all fail.
One day you will abandon prayer.
Another day you will lose your patience.
Another day you will fall into laziness.
Another day you will commit a fault that embarrasses you.
Do not turn one fall into an identity.
Falling does not mean that you have failed definitively.
Get up.
Examine what happened.
Go to confession when there has been mortal sin.
Make amends.
Continue.
20. Saint Augustine: It Is Not Enough to Know the Good; We Must Love It
There is an even deeper problem.
We can know perfectly well what we ought to do and yet fail to do it.
Saint Paul describes this experience dramatically when he speaks of the interior struggle of the person who knows the good but experiences the force of sin.
That is why Christian formation cannot consist merely in transmitting information.
We need to form the will and the affections.
The virtuous person does not merely know that something is good.
He progressively learns to love that good.
This is extremely important.
At first someone may pray because he knows that he should pray.
Then he may come to pray because he wants to pray.
Later he may come to experience a genuine love for prayer.
But we should not wait to feel that love before beginning.
Fidelity often precedes enjoyment.
21. The Christian Must Learn to Do Good Even When Nobody Sees
Contemporary motivation is frequently connected with recognition.
“Let my progress be seen.”
“Let others know that I am working on myself.”
“Let people notice my transformation.”
Christian virtue has another logic.
Christ teaches us to do good even when nobody applauds us.
Because God sees.
A virtuous person may make a sacrifice that nobody will ever know about.
He may reject a temptation that nobody will know he experienced.
He may forgive without announcing it.
He may pray in silence.
He may perform a good deed without posting it online.
He may faithfully fulfill a completely invisible duty.
And precisely there a decisive question emerges:
Who are you when nobody is watching?
There we discover a great deal about character.
22. Spiritual Life Is Not a Succession of Religious Emotions
We must recover this truth.
Christian life has moments of joy.
It has consolation.
It has enthusiasm.
It has tears.
It has fervor.
But it also has tiredness.
Silence.
Dryness.
Difficulty.
Temptation.
Falls.
Waiting.
Perseverance.
And all of this can form part of the journey toward God.
Christianity does not promise that we will feel good every day.
It promises something infinitely greater:
that Christ will be with us.
Therefore our hope cannot depend upon our emotional state.
It depends upon God.
23. Virtue Transforms the Whole Person
Virtue does not simply seek to make us do some good things.
It seeks to transform our way of being.
The ultimate goal is not:
“I want to behave well.”
It is:
“I want to become a good man, by the grace of God.”
That is much deeper.
A prudent person learns to judge correctly.
A just person learns to respect the rights of others.
A strong person learns to remain firm.
A temperate person learns to govern his desires.
A charitable person learns to love.
A humble person learns to live according to the truth about himself.
A religious person learns to recognize God’s sovereignty.
A hopeful person learns to pass through difficulties without falling into despair.
A person of faith learns to live not only according to what is visible, but according to supernatural reality.
This is human and Christian formation.
24. What Are You Building Your Life Upon?
This is perhaps the most important question in the entire article.
What are you building upon?
Your emotions?
Your state of mind?
The recognition of others?
Your successes?
Your work?
Your health?
Your money?
Your relationships?
Your projects?
Your own strength?
All of these things can change.
Illness can come.
Money can disappear.
People can disappoint us.
Work can be lost.
Youth comes to an end.
Projects fail.
Enthusiasm disappears.
And then we discover whether our house was built upon sand or upon rock.
Christ offers us a rock.
Not a feeling.
Not a passing emotion.
Not a motivation technique.
Christ Himself.
25. The Great Spiritual Revolution: Doing Good Even When You Do Not Feel Like It
Perhaps we could summarize this entire article in a single sentence:
Do not wait to feel ready to do good. Form your will to want and do what is good.
When motivation comes, be grateful for it.
When enthusiasm appears, make use of it.
When you experience fervor, use it to move forward.
But when it disappears, do not abandon the journey.
Because authentic love is not demonstrated only when things are pleasant.
True love also knows how to sacrifice.
And here we find the very heart of Christianity.
The Cross is not precisely the symbol of a life governed by motivation.
It is the symbol of a will given in love.
Christ did not remain upon the Cross because it was comfortable.
He did not remain because it was pleasant.
He remained out of love and obedience to the Father.
And there we find the supreme model of Christian life:
not “I do good because I feel like it,” but “I love the good and I am willing to sacrifice myself for it.”
26. A Simple Rule of Life to Begin
If someone wanted to immediately apply everything we have discussed, he could begin with something very simple.
Every Morning
When you get up, do not think first:
“How do I feel?”
Think:
“What does God expect from me today?”
Make a brief prayer of offering.
During the Day
Choose one particular virtue.
For example:
Today I will practice patience.
And when the opportunity arises, remember your resolution.
When Facing a Difficulty
Do not ask only:
“Why is this happening to me?”
Also ask:
“What virtue can I practice here?”
A setback can become patience.
An injustice can become fortitude.
A provocation can become self-control.
Tiredness can become sacrifice.
An unpleasant obligation can become fidelity.
At Night
Make an examination of conscience.
Not only:
“What did I do wrong?”
Also ask:
“Where did I respond to the good? Where did I cooperate with grace? Where did I give in to my passions?”
Give thanks.
Ask forgiveness.
Make one concrete resolution for improvement.
And begin again tomorrow.
Conclusion: Do Not Build on Sand
Motivation has its place.
But it cannot be the foundation of a life.
It is too changeable.
Today it is present.
Tomorrow it disappears.
Then it returns.
Then it disappears again.
It is like the wind.
Virtue, on the other hand, seeks to root the good within us.
And Christian life goes even further: it is not simply about acquiring good human habits, but about allowing God’s grace to transform our faculties, our affections, our will, and ultimately our entire life.
Therefore, we should not build our existence upon:
“I feel like it.”
We should build it upon:
“This is good.”
Not upon:
“I feel strong.”
But upon:
“God will give me the grace to persevere.”
Not upon:
“I am motivated.”
But upon:
“I have decided to be faithful.”
Not upon the enthusiasm of one day.
But upon the fidelity of an entire life.
Our Lord left this truth to us in an image that has crossed the centuries:
“The one who hears my words and puts them into practice is like a wise man who built his house on rock.” (biblegateway.com)
And the rock is not our motivation.
It is not our willpower.
It is not our ability to organize ourselves.
The rock is Christ.
Upon that rock we can build good habits.
Upon those habits we can cultivate virtues.
Through those virtues we can order our lives.
And through grace we can advance toward that for which we were created:
to know, love, and serve God in this life, so that we may enjoy Him eternally in the next.
Because in the end, the decisive question will not be:
“How many days were you motivated?”
It will be much simpler and much deeper:
“Were you faithful?”
And that fidelity, day after day, especially when we do not feel like it, is one of the most concrete ways of beginning to build a truly Christian life.
