Related Articles
Introduction: What is Justification Really?
Many Christians today hear about the “theory of justification” as if it were an abstract or secondary issue—something that divided Catholics and Protestants centuries ago, but with little relevance to daily life. However, nothing could be further from the truth.
Justification is at the very heart of the Christian life. It involves the salvation of the soul. How does man pass from sin to grace? What does it mean to truly be a child of God? Is having faith enough for salvation, or are works also necessary? Is salvation an external act of God or an interior transformation?
This article is not just a doctrinal explanation—it is a spiritual and pastoral guide to rediscovering the true Catholic theory of justification, learning to live it, and defending it against Protestant errors. We will explore it through the clarity and beauty of traditional Catholic faith, guided by Scripture, Tradition, and the Magisterium.
I. What Does the Catholic Church Teach About Justification?
According to the Catechism of the Catholic Church (§1987), justification is:
“the most excellent work of God’s love: it is the passing from the state in which man is born as a child of the first Adam to the state of grace and adoption as sons of God through the second Adam, Jesus Christ.”
In other words, justification is not merely God declaring us righteous in a legal or external sense, but rather truly making us righteous by transforming our soul through His grace.
This doctrine is not just another theory, but the secure teaching of the Gospel, lived from the earliest centuries by the saints and solemnly defined by the Council of Trent in response to the errors of Luther and other reformers.
II. Biblical and Patristic Roots of the Catholic Theory of Justification
St. Paul: Faith, Grace, and Charity
Many Protestants quote St. Paul to defend “justification by faith alone.” But this is an incomplete and decontextualized reading. St. Paul clearly teaches:
“Therefore, since we are justified by faith, we have peace with God through our Lord Jesus Christ” (Romans 5:1).
However, in Galatians 5:6 he clarifies that it is:
“faith working through love.”
This means that faith alone does not justify. This is the key truth preserved by the Catholic Church and denied by Protestantism: faith alone is not sufficient; it must be living, fruitful, and accompanied by charity, hope, and good works born of grace.
The Church Fathers
Saints such as St. Irenaeus, St. Augustine, and St. Jerome never spoke of a “forensic” or merely “imputed” justification, as Protestant theology does. For them, grace truly transforms the human person, making him a temple of the Holy Spirit.
III. Luther and the Break: The Error of “Sola Fide”
The Protestant theory of justification was born with Martin Luther in the 16th century. According to him:
- Man does not cooperate with God in his justification.
- Faith alone is sufficient for salvation.
- Works have no value in the salvation process.
- Grace does not transform man, but merely “covers” him like a cloak over sin.
This doctrine was a radical break from the apostolic and patristic faith. To say that God does not transform the soul but simply “declares the sinner righteous” without changing his inner state undermines divine holiness and denies the effectiveness of Christ’s redemption.
IV. The Council of Trent: The Authentic Catholic Theory of Justification
In response to the Lutheran error, the Council of Trent (1545–1563) offered a masterful and authoritative response, defining with precision what justification is and how it works in the soul.
Essential Elements of Justification According to Trent:
- It is a free gift from God, not earned by human merit.
- It requires the free cooperation of man.
- It includes both the forgiveness of sins and inner sanctification.
- It occurs through grace received in Baptism (or through Confession, if already baptized).
- Good works done in grace increase justification.
“If anyone says that man is justified by faith alone, without any cooperation on the part of his will, let him be anathema.” (Council of Trent, Session VI, Canon 4)
V. How Does Justification Happen in the Life of the Christian?
1. It Begins with Baptism
Baptism is the first moment of justification. It removes original sin, imparts sanctifying grace, and incorporates us into Christ.
“Unless one is born of water and the Spirit, he cannot enter the kingdom of God” (John 3:5)
2. It Is Strengthened by Living Faith
Faith is the soul’s response to God, but it must be united with charity. As St. James says:
“You see that a man is justified by works and not by faith alone” (James 2:24)
3. It Is Restored Through Confession
If grace is lost through mortal sin, justification can be regained through the sacrament of Confession, with sincere contrition and a firm purpose of amendment.
VI. Living Justified: A Spiritual and Pastoral Guide
1. Remain in a State of Grace
- Frequent Confession (at least monthly)
- Avoid all mortal sin
- Never receive Holy Communion in a state of grave sin
2. Nourish the Life of Grace
- Attend Sunday Mass (and daily Mass if possible)
- Worthily receive Holy Communion
- Spend time in personal prayer each day
3. Practice Works of Charity
Works do not “buy” heaven, but they are living signs of grace. Helping the poor, forgiving others, teaching the faith, visiting the sick—these acts increase our justification and merit before God.
4. Study the Catholic Faith
To avoid being misled by Protestant errors or superficial Catholicism, one must know and love the faith. Study the Catechism, read the lives of the saints, and delve into Sacred Scripture with the guidance of the Magisterium.
VII. Protestant Objections Clearly Refuted
| Protestant Objection | Catholic Response |
|---|---|
| “Salvation is by faith alone” | James 2:24: “A man is justified by works and not by faith alone.” |
| “Works are worthless” | Romans 2:6: “God will repay each person according to what they have done.” |
| “God merely declares us righteous” | 2 Corinthians 5:17: “If anyone is in Christ, he is a new creation.” (real transformation) |
| “Once saved, always saved” | 1 Corinthians 10:12: “Whoever thinks he is standing firm should be careful not to fall.” |
VIII. Conclusion: The True Theory That Saves
The Catholic theory of justification is not merely an intellectual construct, but a divinely revealed truth that reaches the core of our existence. To be justified does not merely mean “declared innocent,” but rather to be made children of God, sharers in His divine life.
It is not enough simply to believe; we must live in grace, act in charity, and persevere to the end. This is the Catholic faith, the faith of the ages, the only faith that truly saves.
“By grace you have been saved through faith, and this is not from you; it is the gift of God” (Ephesians 2:8)
IX. Final Recommendations for Living as the Justified
✅ Pray daily for perseverance in grace.
✅ Go frequently to the sacrament of Confession.
✅ Avoid all grave sin as you would poison.
✅ Practice acts of charity with humility.
✅ Study and defend the Church’s doctrine firmly.
In Romans 4:2-3 Paul clarifies James 2:24 on Abraham’s justification by works. Paul states that Abraham’s works were not justified before God. If not by God, then it is by men or in sight of men. Paul also stated that Abraham was declared righteous because he believed God, that’s faith. Paul makes it perfectly clear as to what James was referring to on justification by works. In Romans 3:28 it states that being justified by faith without the deeds of the law. Ephesians 2:8-9 doesn’t need to add alone to the word faith because it states that salvation is by grace through faith and not works. It’s like saying, 10 people were inside a room, but 9 decided to leave the room. I don’t need to say that one person is now alone in that room when the other 9 left. If works is excluded and only faith remains in Ephesians 2:8-9, then isn’t faith really alone? Justification is by faith not works, Paul clarified James 2:24. Thank you.
Dear Brother in Christ,
Thank you for sharing your thoughts with such a deep interest in Sacred Scripture. It is beautiful to see how we seek together to understand God’s Word. Allow me to respond with charity and clarity, from the perspective of Catholic teaching, which is rooted in the entirety of the Bible and Apostolic Tradition.
1. The Complementarity Between Paul and James:
St. Paul (in Romans 4 and Ephesians 2) emphasizes that justification comes through faith, not by the works of the Mosaic Law (such as circumcision or purely external rituals). This is true, and the Church proclaims it emphatically: no one is saved by their own merits, but by God’s grace received through faith!
However, James (in 2:24) speaks of works as the indispensable fruit of living faith. They do not contradict each other but complement one another: Paul condemns faith without works (Romans 2:6-8), and James condemns dead faith (2:17). Both teach that authentic faith “works through love” (Galatians 5:6).
2. Abraham: Faith and Obedience:
Paul cites Genesis 15:6 (when Abraham believed), while James refers to Genesis 22 (when Abraham offered Isaac). God declared him righteous because of his faith, but that faith was demonstrated through his obedience. As Jesus says: “Not everyone who says to me, ‘Lord, Lord,’ will enter the kingdom of heaven, but only the one who does the will of my Father” (Matthew 7:21).
3. Ephesians 2:8-10:
Yes! Salvation is a pure gift from God (grace through faith). But the very next verse (v. 10) adds: “For we are God’s handiwork, created in Christ Jesus to do good works, which God prepared in advance for us to do.” Works do not “earn” salvation, but they are the evidence that grace is at work within us.
4. Faith “Alone”:
The issue is not faith itself, but the word “alone” added by some Protestant brothers. The Bible never says “faith alone” (except in James 2:24, where it denies the idea). Even Paul insists on “faith working through love” (Galatians 5:6). Grace transforms the heart, and that love always bears fruit in works (Matthew 25:31-46).
5. The Early Church and Tradition:
The Church Fathers (like St. Augustine and St. John Chrysostom) always taught this unity between faith and works. Even Luther, when translating Romans 3:28, added the word “alone” (which is not in the original Greek), revealing it as a human interpretation, not a biblical one.
Conclusion:
Dear brother, faith is the beginning of salvation, but it must be living, like a tree that bears fruit (John 15:1-5). The Catholic Church joyfully proclaims that “God saves us freely,” but also calls us to “work out your salvation with fear and trembling” (Philippians 2:12), because He wants co-workers, not spectators.
Let us continue this dialogue with love, seeking truth in Christ, who is the Way, the Truth, and the Life.
A fraternal embrace in Christ,