Related Articles
A spiritual guide to understanding the deeper movements that shape the life of the Church
Introduction: Beyond Colors, the Battle for the Soul of the Church
When cardinals gather behind closed doors in the Sistine Chapel to elect a new Pope, the whole world holds its breath. But what may seem like a solemn election to many is, for others, also the final act of a battle that has been unfolding for years—even centuries. At the heart of this silent and spiritual struggle resounds an ancient conflict, often symbolized by two powerful figures within Catholicism: the so-called ‘Red Pope’ (the Prefect of the Congregation for the Evangelization of Peoples, traditionally linked to missionary interests) and the ‘Black Pope’ (the Superior General of the Society of Jesus, called so because of his black cassock and his immense global influence).
Although neither is literally a pope, both embody two ways of understanding service, power, and the Church’s mission in the world. This article does not intend to fuel conspiracy theories, but rather to offer a theological, historical, and pastoral reflection on how major ecclesial decisions are shaped—and what we can learn from them in our own spiritual lives.
“For our struggle is not against flesh and blood, but against the rulers, against the authorities, against the powers of this dark world, and against the spiritual forces of evil in the heavenly realms.”
Ephesians 6:12
I. Historical Origins of Two Ecclesiastical Symbols
Who Is the ‘Red Pope’?
The term “Red Pope” colloquially refers to the Prefect of the Congregation (now Dicastery) for the Evangelization of Peoples, formerly known as “Propaganda Fide.” Founded in 1622 by Pope Gregory XV, this institution was tasked with bringing the Gospel to all nations, especially those where Christianity was unknown.
The “red” comes from the cardinal’s red vestments traditionally worn by the head of this Congregation. However, his role has been not only pastoral but also strategic, overseeing the Church’s efforts in politically and spiritually sensitive territories.
And Who Is the ‘Black Pope’?
The “Black Pope” is the Superior General of the Society of Jesus, the order founded by St. Ignatius of Loyola in 1540. The Jesuits’ black cassock gave rise to the nickname, but so did their far-reaching influence in education, diplomacy, intellectual circles, and sometimes even politics. Over the centuries, Jesuits have been staunch defenders of the papacy—but also powerful shapers of theology and modern Catholic thought.
II. The Inner Tension: Missionary Vision vs. Reformist Vision
These two figures represent two great souls of the Church:
- The “Red Pope” embodies an external, evangelizing, missionary dimension, concerned with spreading Catholic doctrine while remaining faithful to Tradition.
- The “Black Pope” represents a more internal, reformist, world-engaging dimension, seeking to adapt to the times and rethink ecclesial structures without losing the essence.
This tension is not necessarily negative. The Church, as the Body of Christ, needs both lungs: the firmness of faith and the ability to discern the signs of the times. But when one of these poles dominates without listening to the other, it creates an ecclesial imbalance that can lead to crisis.
III. The Conclave: A Spiritual Battlefield
When the time comes to elect a Pope, these visions clash through the cardinals—many of whom belong to or are influenced by religious orders. Some push for a more doctrinal and hierarchical Church; others for a more pastoral and synodal one. This is where the image of the conclave as an invisible spiritual battleground takes root.
It is not a mere political struggle but a theological combat:
- What should the Church look like in the 21st century?
- Should it reaffirm Tradition or open new paths of dialogue with the modern world?
- Should it preserve its hierarchical structure or reform it in a synodal direction?
IV. What About the People of God? Implications for the Faithful
This battle is not foreign to ordinary Catholics. The division between fidelity and reform is also felt in our parishes, families, and hearts. Many faithful feel disoriented: Whom should we listen to? What is the true face of the Church? How can we live the faith amid these tensions?
Here lies the most important pastoral response: return to Christ as the center. Neither the “Red Pope” nor the “Black Pope” is our Savior. Christ alone is Lord. As the Catechism teaches: “The supreme model of faith is Mary” (CCC 149)—not an ideologue or a church official.
V. Theological Keys to Understanding Unity in Diversity
- The Church Is One and Diverse
- “There are different kinds of gifts, but the same Spirit.” (1 Corinthians 12:4)
- The richness of religious orders, spiritual movements, and doctrinal perspectives are part of the Spirit’s dynamic action. Not every disagreement is division; often it is simply plurality.
- The Holy Spirit Guides the Conclave
- Although cardinals are men with flaws, the Church firmly believes that the Spirit acts mysteriously in the election of the Pope. This does not mean the best man is always chosen, but that God allows the election for His greater purpose in that historical moment.
- Tradition and Renewal Are Not Opposed
- Pope Benedict XVI spoke of the “hermeneutic of continuity.” Every true reform must emerge from a faithful reading of the Church’s living Tradition, not in rupture with it.
- The Laity Has a Fundamental Role
- We cannot leave everything to the hierarchy. Every baptized person is called to live and guard the faith, being “the salt of the earth and the light of the world” (Matthew 5:13–14).
VI. Practical Applications: What Can We Do?
1. Pray Without Ceasing for the Church
“Pray without ceasing.” (1 Thessalonians 5:17)
Our first mission is to pray for our shepherds—for the Pope, for the cardinals, for the consecrated, and for every faithful soul.
2. Grow in Knowledge of the Faith
Discouragement and confusion often grow where ignorance reigns. Study the Catechism, read the Holy Scriptures, and learn about Church history. Only then will you avoid being swept away by ideological trends.
3. Live Unity Through Charity
Even if you see tensions in the Church, do not take sides as if it were a political match. Live unity in your community, your family, and your environment—with humility and obedience to the Magisterium.
4. Discern Spiritually
Not everything that appears modern comes from the Spirit, and not everything traditional is faithful just because it is old. Discern in the light of the Gospel and in communion with the Church.
5. Evangelize Through Coherence
Both the “Red Pope” and the “Black Pope” represent missionary models. What is yours? Are you evangelizing with your life? With your example? With your words? The world needs witnesses—not ideologues.
Conclusion: Beyond the Battles, the Cross of Christ
The Church’s history is full of struggles, tensions, schisms, and reforms. But it is also full of saints, martyrs, and missionaries who, regardless of ecclesial battles, lived and died for Christ.
Today more than ever, we are called to be faithful and bold. We do not need red or black popes—we need Christians with burning hearts, capable of living the faith with joy, speaking the truth, and loving without fear.
“Be on your guard; stand firm in the faith; be courageous; be strong. Do everything in love.”
1 Corinthians 16:13–14
Pastoral and Theological Guide for Readers
| Aspect | Suggested Action | Theological Foundation |
|---|---|---|
| Prayer | Dedicate daily prayer for the Pope and the unity of the Church | “For where two or three are gathered in my name, there am I among them.” (Mt 18:20) |
| Formation | Read 10 minutes of the Catechism or the Bible each day | “My people are destroyed for lack of knowledge.” (Hosea 4:6) |
| Communion | Participate in parish groups, adoration, or community rosaries | “They all joined together constantly in prayer.” (Acts 1:14) |
| Evangelization | Share Catholic content online with faith and respect | “Preach the Gospel to every creature.” (Mark 16:15) |
| Discernment | Consult a priest or spiritual guide when in doubt | “Whoever listens to you listens to me.” (Luke 10:16) |
Epilogue: Your Role in the History of the Church
You are not a spectator. You are a living member of the Body of Christ. It doesn’t matter if you live in a city, in the countryside, in a hospital, a prison, or your home. Right there, in your concrete life, you can renew the Church—not through power, but through love.
Because the true battle is not fought in the Sistine Chapel…
It is fought in your heart.
