Related Articles
Introduction: A Secret That Sparks Controversy
The year 1929 is remembered for the Lateran Treaty that established the Vatican as a sovereign state. However, rumors persist about a dark event: the alleged mass burning of the Vatican’s secret archives that same year. How much truth is there to these claims? Why does this remain a controversial topic nearly a century later?
This article examines the evidence, testimonies, and historical gaps surrounding this mystery, distinguishing verifiable facts from speculative theories, and explores its relevance for Catholics today.
1. Historical Context: Why Is 1929 Suspect?
A. The Lateran Treaty and the Need to “Clean Up” the Past
In February 1929, the Vatican and Fascist Italy signed the Lateran Treaty, ending decades of tension. But this political agreement may have come with an unwritten condition: to eliminate compromising documents about Church-State relations.
B. The Fight Against Freemasonry
Freemasonry had been condemned by the Church since the encyclical Humanum Genus (Leo XIII, 1884). In the 1920s, many Italian Freemasons held key government positions. Did the Vatican destroy evidence of Masonic infiltration in the clergy?
C. Vatican Secrecy
Until 2020, the Vatican Apostolic Archives (formerly “Secret”) only allowed access to documents up to 1939. This secrecy fuels theories about what might have been hidden—or burned—during eras like that of Pius XI (1922-1939).
2. Which Documents Are Said to Have Been Destroyed?
A. Files on Masonic Infiltration
- Fact: We know the Church investigated clergy linked to lodges.
- Unconfirmed: That evidence of Masonic cardinals or bishops was burned in 1929.
B. “Dangerous” Prophecies
- Fact: Texts like the Prophecy of the Popes (attributed to St. Malachy) were criticized by the Church for lacking rigor.
- Myth: No proof exists of a mass destruction of prophecies that year.
C. Heresies and Hidden Scandals
Some historians suggest documents on antipopes, schisms, or abuses may have been eliminated to protect the Church’s image.
3. Is There Evidence of Archive Burning in 1929?
Indirect Testimonies
- Jesuit Peter Gumpel (Vatican archives expert) admitted some “sensitive” documents were destroyed before public release.
- Historian David Álvarez documented selective purges in various eras, though not specifically 1929.
Lack of Direct Evidence
- No photos, minutes, or official records of a mass burning that year.
- It may be confused with other purges (e.g., under Pius X or Pius XII).
4. Why Does the Theory Persist?
A. Vatican Secrecy
The policy of releasing archives decades later (e.g., Pius XII’s in 2020) fuels suspicions.
B. Interest in Conspiracies
Since The Da Vinci Code, theories about what the Vatican “hides” have proliferated. Reality is often less sensational.
C. Valid Lessons, Even If Details Are Unclear
Even if the 1929 burning is unconfirmed, it’s true that:
- The Church has destroyed sensitive documents in other cases (e.g., Inquisition archives).
- The fight against secret societies like Freemasonry was real.
- Some private prophecies were dismissed by the Church for lacking foundation.
5. Lessons for Catholics Today
- Transparency vs. Prudence: The Church must balance historical truth with safeguarding the faith.
- Vigilance Against Secret Ideologies: Modern Freemasonry and other societies still influence politics and culture.
- Discerning Revelation from Superstition: Not all “prophecies” come from God (cf. 1 Jn 4:1).
Conclusion: A Mystery That Invites Reflection, Not Conspiracy
Were archives burned in 1929? It’s plausible, but not conclusively proven. What matters is:
- Avoiding myths (e.g., that the Vatican is hiding “the end of the world”).
- Learning from the past to live a stronger faith today.
What do you think? Should the Vatican open all its archives, or are some secrets necessary?
✝️ Want to go deeper? We recommend:
- “The Vatican’s Secret Archives” (Grzegorz Górny).
- “The Church and Freemasonry: History of a Condemnation” (Massimo Introvigne).
Share this article for an informed debate!
