Related Articles
The history of Christianity is not the history of a comfortable faith, but of a faith put to the test.
Every time a heresy tried to distort the face of Christ, the Church responded not with improvisation, but with prayer, study, suffering, and finally with Councils.
Where confusion arose, the Church clarified.
Where error appeared, the Church defined.
Where the faith was attacked, the Church guarded the Deposit received from the Apostles.
This article seeks to help you understand why heresies did not destroy the Church, but mysteriously forced her to go deeper into the Truth, and how those ancient debates directly illuminate the doctrinal and pastoral problems of today.
1. What is a heresy… and why does God allow it?
A heresy is not simply an innocent theological mistake. In the classical sense, it is:
The obstinate denial of a truth that must be believed with divine and Catholic faith.
That is to say, it is not ignorance, but resistance to a known Truth.
Saint Paul already warned:
“For the time will come when people will not tolerate sound doctrine; but following their own desires and insatiable curiosity, they will accumulate teachers and stop listening to the truth” (2 Tim 4:3).
God does not will heresy, but He permits it for a greater good:
👉 to force the Church to formulate precisely what she has always believed.
Before heresy, many truths were lived; afterwards, they were defined.
2. What is a Council? Much more than a meeting
An ecumenical council is the highest expression of the Church’s solemn Magisterium, where the bishops, in communion with the Pope, define doctrines binding on all the faithful.
They do not invent anything new.
They defend, clarify, and specify what was already contained in Revelation.
Jesus promised it:
“When the Spirit of truth comes, he will guide you into all the truth” (Jn 16:13).
3. The great heresies… and the Councils that overcame them
🔥 ARIANISM – Is Jesus God… or a creature?
Heresy: Arius claimed that the Son was neither eternal nor consubstantial with the Father.
Consequence: Christ would no longer be truly God.
🛡 Council of Nicaea I (325)
Key definition:
“Begotten, not made, consubstantial (homoousios) with the Father.”
👉 Current impact:
Every time Jesus is reduced to a “moral teacher,” a “spiritual leader,” or a “prophet,” Arianism returns dressed in modern clothes.
🔥 NESTORIANISM – Is Mary the Mother of God?
Heresy: Nestorius separated Christ into two persons, one divine and one human.
Mary would be only the mother of the “man Jesus.”
🛡 Council of Ephesus (431)
Definition:
Mary is Theotokos, Mother of God.
👉 Current impact:
Whenever the “historical Jesus” is separated from the “Christ of faith,” Nestorius speaks again.
🔥 MONOPHYSITISM – Does Christ have only one nature?
Heresy: It denied Christ’s true humanity after the Incarnation.
🛡 Council of Chalcedon (451)
Magisterial definition:
One single Person in two natures, without confusion, without change, without division, without separation.
👉 Current impact:
Every form of spiritualism that despises the body, sacrifice, and the Cross draws from this root.
🔥 PELAGIANISM – Do we save ourselves?
Heresy: It denied original sin and the necessity of grace.
🛡 Councils of Carthage (418) and Orange (529)
Definition:
Grace is absolutely necessary for salvation.
👉 Current impact:
Moralism without grace, the idea that “being a good person is enough,” is recycled Pelagianism.
🔥 DONATISM – Do the sacraments depend on the holiness of the priest?
Heresy: If the minister was sinful, the sacrament was invalid.
🛡 Councils of Arles and Carthage (4th–5th centuries)
Definition:
The sacraments act ex opere operato, by Christ, not by the minister.
👉 Current impact:
Real scandals do not invalidate real grace. The Church is holy even when her members are sinners.
🔥 ICONOCLASM – Are images idolatry?
Heresy: Rejection of sacred images.
🛡 Second Council of Nicaea (787)
Definition:
Images are venerated, not adored.
👉 Current impact:
The symbolic and aesthetic emptying of churches impoverishes the faith.
🔥 PROTESTANTISM – Faith without works? Bible without the Church?
Multiple doctrinal errors:
– Sola Scriptura
– Sola Fide
– Denial of the sacraments
🛡 Council of Trent (1545–1563)
Definitions:
– Faith and works
– Biblical canon
– Sacraments
– The Mass as sacrifice
👉 Current impact:
Much “Catholic” language today is Protestant without realizing it.
🔥 MODERNISM – Faith adapted to the taste of the world
Heresy: Truth changes with culture.
🛡 First Vatican Council (1870)
Definition:
Faith does not contradict reason, but transcends it.
(Saint Pius X would later call it “the synthesis of all heresies”).
👉 Current impact:
When doctrine is diluted to avoid discomfort, modernism smiles.
4. Practical guide: living today with conciliar faith (theological and pastoral)
📿 1. Love doctrine: it is an act of charity
Truth does not oppress, it liberates (Jn 8:32).
📿 2. Do not oppose “pastoral care” to “doctrine”
True pastoral care flows from truth, not from ambiguity.
📿 3. Learn to detect modern heresies
– Moral relativism
– A reduced Christology
– Sacraments reduced to symbols
– Grace without conversion
📿 4. Live in communion with the perennial Magisterium
Not every change is progress.
Not every novelty is authentic development.
📿 5. Pray for the Church
Councils were born from crises, not from comfort.
5. Conclusion: Truth always triumphs
Heresies pass.
Councils remain.
Errors shout.
Truth waits… and finally prevails.
As Saint Vincent of Lérins wrote:
“In the Church there is progress, but without altering the faith; development, but no transformation.”
Today, as yesterday, we do not need a new faith, but the faith of always, lived courageously today.
Because when error multiplies,
clarity becomes an act of love.
