Related Articles
(A deep reflection and practical guide in the light of CCC 2091–2092)
Introduction: when hope becomes distorted
We live in paradoxical times. On the one hand, we speak more than ever about “optimism,” “self-esteem,” or “positive thinking.” On the other hand, interior exhaustion, existential anguish, and the feeling that “nothing is worth it anymore” have become increasingly common. In this context, the theological virtue of hope—so central to the Christian life—is constantly threatened by two opposite but equally dangerous distortions: presumption and despair.
The Catechism of the Catholic Church, with the lucidity characteristic of Tradition, clearly warns against these two sins against hope in numbers 2091 and 2092. This is not a theoretical warning nor outdated moralism, but a profoundly current, pastoral, and liberating teaching.
This article seeks to help you understand, discern, and live authentic Christian hope, avoiding these two spiritual abysses that threaten both the lukewarm believer and the fervent one.
1. Christian hope: far more than “being positive”
Before speaking about its enemies, we must recall what hope truly is.
Christian hope is not:
- naïveté,
- psychological optimism,
- nor blind confidence that “everything will turn out fine.”
Hope is a theological virtue, infused by God into the soul at Baptism, by which we desire and expect from God eternal life and the means necessary to attain it, trusting not in our own strength, but in His fidelity and mercy.
Saint Paul expresses this with striking force:
“Hope does not disappoint, because the love of God has been poured into our hearts through the Holy Spirit who has been given to us” (Romans 5:5).
Authentic hope always lives in tension:
- it trusts completely in God,
- yet humbly acknowledges one’s own fragility.
When that tension breaks, presumption or despair appear.
2. Presumption: trusting in God… without God
The Catechism teaches:
“There are two kinds of presumption. Either man presumes upon his own capacities (hoping to be able to save himself without help from on high), or he presumes upon God’s almighty power or his mercy (hoping to obtain his forgiveness without conversion and glory without merit)” (CCC 2092).
What is presumption, at its core?
Presumption is a false hope. It looks like trust, but in reality it is spiritual pride. It presents itself in two main forms:
1. Presumption of self-sufficiency
- “I’m a good person; I don’t need confession.”
- “God isn’t going to ask that much of me.”
- “As long as I don’t hurt anyone, that’s enough.”
Here God is reduced to a complacent spectator. Grace is no longer necessary. Christ goes from being Savior to merely a moral companion.
2. Presumption of a mercy without conversion
- “God forgives everything, no matter what.”
- “I’ll confess later, when I’m older.”
- “God is love; He doesn’t punish.”
This form is especially dangerous because it uses God against God: it invokes His mercy to justify sin.
Saint Paul responds sharply to this mentality:
“Are we to continue in sin that grace may abound? By no means!” (Romans 6:1–2).
Spiritual roots of presumption
- Pride disguised as confidence.
- Loss of the sense of sin.
- A sentimental reduction of God.
- Forgetfulness of judgment, of the Cross, and of the need for grace.
Presumption numbs the conscience and extinguishes the desire for conversion.
3. Despair: doubting the love of God
The Catechism teaches:
“By despair, man ceases to hope for his personal salvation from God, for help in attaining it or for the forgiveness of his sins” (CCC 2091).
What is despair?
Despair is a deep wound in filial trust. It does not always manifest as rebellion; often it appears as weariness, shame, or spiritual self-contempt.
Typical phrases of the despairing person:
- “God cannot forgive me for this.”
- “I have sinned too much.”
- “I’m not cut out to be a Christian.”
- “I always fall into the same thing.”
Here the problem is not minimizing sin, but magnifying it until it becomes greater than God’s mercy.
Paradoxically, despair is also a form of pride: sin is placed above the Cross.
Judas and Peter: two falls, two paths
Both betrayed Jesus.
- Judas despaired and closed himself to forgiveness.
- Peter wept bitterly, but hoped in mercy.
The difference was not the sin, but hope.
“The Lord is merciful and gracious, slow to anger and abounding in steadfast love” (Psalm 103:8).
4. Presumption and despair: two extremes, the same error
Although they seem opposed, both share a fundamental mistake:
👉 not accepting God as He truly is.
- Presumption forgets His holiness and justice.
- Despair forgets His mercy and fidelity.
Authentic hope lives in the center:
- it fears offending God,
- yet always trusts in His forgiveness.
5. A rigorous practical guide: living hope from a theological and pastoral perspective
A. To combat presumption
- Recover the sense of sin
- Not to live in fear, but in truth.
- Serious and regular examination of conscience.
- Frequent the Sacrament of Reconciliation
- Not only “when there is mortal sin.”
- Confession educates humility and heals presumption.
- Meditate on the Passion of Christ
- The Cross reveals the true cost of sin.
- Whoever contemplates the Cross does not trivialize grace.
- Practice obedience
- To the teaching of the Church.
- To Christian morality even when it is demanding.
B. To heal despair
- Contemplate revealed mercy
- The parable of the prodigal son.
- Jesus with the adulterous woman, the good thief, Peter.
- Separate the sin from the sinner
- God hates sin, but loves the sinner infinitely.
- Your fall does not define your identity.
- Persevere even when you fall
- Holiness is not never falling, but always rising again.
- Hope is exercised in struggle, not in perfection.
- Seek spiritual accompaniment
- Isolation feeds despair.
- The Church is a mother, not a faceless tribunal.
6. A final word for our time
Today many Christians live trapped between:
- a comfortable faith that does not convert (presumption),
- and an anguished faith that paralyzes (despair).
Christian hope is something else:
- it does not promise a life without the Cross,
- but it guarantees that no cross is useless.
“Those who hope in the Lord shall renew their strength” (Isaiah 40:31).
Conclusion: learning to hope as sons and daughters
Hope is not a feeling; it is a decision sustained by grace. Presumption and despair are two ways of ceasing to hope as children and beginning to live as slaves: either to oneself, or to fear.
May this teaching of the Catechism not remain theoretical. May it become daily discernment, humble trust, and a path of serene conversion.
Because the Christian does not walk confident in himself…
he walks confident in God.
