Related Articles
Introduction: A Document That Shook the World
In 1864, at the height of liberal revolutions, Pope Pius IX published one of the most controversial and misunderstood documents in Church history: the Syllabus Errorum (or “Catalog of Errors”). Attached to the encyclical Quanta Cura, this text condemned 80 propositions deemed contrary to the faith and Christian social order. Among them, one in particular has sparked debate to this day: the condemnation of liberal democracy and religious relativism.
Why would a Pope oppose democracy? Does the Church reject freedom? What did Pius IX have against the modern world? These questions are far from merely historical—they hold urgent relevance today, in an age where truth is relative, faith is diluted, and governments promote ideologies opposed to Catholic morality.
In this article, we will explore:
- The historical context of the Syllabus: What was happening in the 19th century?
- The condemned errors: Why did Pius IX reject liberal democracy?
- The controversy and misinterpretations.
- The relevance of the Syllabus in the 21st century: Does it have something to say to us today?
1. The World That Provoked Pius IX’s Wrath
To understand the Syllabus, we must go back to the 19th century, a time of revolutions, secularization, and direct attacks against the Church.
The French Revolution and Its Aftermath
- The Revolution (1789) had overthrown monarchies, guillotined priests, and proclaimed the cult of Reason in place of God.
- Governments emerged that expelled the Church from public life, confiscated its property, and persecuted Catholics.
- Liberalism (not in the economic sense, but the ideological one) promoted the idea that religion was a private matter and that the State should be neutral.
The Risorgimento and the Loss of the Papal States
- Italy was unifying under an anti-clerical government that invaded papal territories.
- Pius IX, initially seen as a reformer, became the great defender of Tradition against revolutionary ideas.
In this context, the Syllabus was not a whim but a necessary response to a civilization seeking to erase God from society.
2. What Exactly Did the Syllabus Errorum Condemn?
The document lists 80 errors, divided into categories such as:
- Rationalism and naturalism (denial of Revelation).
- Religious liberalism (the idea that all religions are equal).
- Socialism and communism (condemned before Marx gained influence).
- Errors concerning the Church and the State.
The Condemnation of Liberal Democracy
One of the most debated points is Proposition 80, which rejects the idea that:
“The Roman Pontiff can and should reconcile himself with progress, liberalism, and modern civilization.”
Does this mean the Church is against democracy? Not exactly.
- Pius IX was not condemning all forms of popular government, but rather the liberalism that excludes God from public life.
- The modern democracy of the 19th century sought to build a society without Christ, where morality was decided by majority vote, not natural law.
- Today, we see the fruits of this: governments promoting abortion, gender ideology, and religious persecution.
Other Key Condemnations
- Unlimited freedom of worship (Error #15): The Church cannot accept that error has the same rights as truth.
- Total separation of Church and State (Error #55): Civil authority cannot ignore God.
3. The Controversy: Was Pius IX a Reactionary?
The Syllabus was met with outrage in Europe. Secularists used it to paint the Church as an enemy of freedom.
Common Misinterpretations
- “The Church hates freedom”: False. The Church defends true freedom (the kind that leads to God), not license.
- “The Pope wanted to maintain privileges”: In reality, Pius IX defended Christ’s right to reign over nations.
- “It’s an obsolete document”: Its warnings are more relevant today than ever.
4. The Syllabus in the 21st Century: What Does It Say to Us Today?
We live in a new age of errors:
- Dictatorship of relativism (as warned by Benedict XVI).
- Governments imposing immoral laws (abortion, euthanasia).
- Christians persecuted in the West not by swords, but by laws and censorship.
Lessons for Today
- Not all progress is good: Technology advances, but morality declines.
- Democracy without God leads to tyranny: When truth is put to a vote, error wins.
- The Church cannot surrender to the world: Like Pius IX, we must stand firm in the truth, even if the world calls us “intolerant.”
Conclusion: Was Pius IX a Prophet?
The Syllabus Errorum was not an act of hatred but of love for truth. Pius IX saw where the world was heading and warned us.
Today, as Western nations deny their Christian heritage, as faith is ridiculed and the family destroyed, the Syllabus echoes as a prophetic cry:
“You cannot serve both God and the world.”
The question is: Which one do you serve?
Did you like this article? Share it and keep exploring true Catholic doctrine. “The truth will set you free” (John 8:32).
